Through His Eyes

The blindfold was already on the nightstand when I walked in, folded with that neatness of his that always made me smile. The rope, next to the lamp. That alone was enough to give my stomach a small drop, the good kind.

I never knew what we’d do on any given night. That was never the point. It was the arrangement we’d spent months refining before we finally put words to it, standing in the kitchen, in the tone people use for things serious enough that you only want to say them once: I handed him full control of every game. He decided what, how, when. I didn’t ask beforehand. I trusted after.

There were lines, of course. Nothing that could leave a real mark, nothing irreversible, nothing that touched my life outside that room: my job, my family, my face turning up somewhere it shouldn’t. Within that, he had permission to surprise me, and he exercised it with something close to craftsmanship: he never told me the plan in advance, because he said the surprise was half the gift.

“And if I don’t like something?” I’d asked him, the first time we talked about this for real.

“Then you say so. Red, and it stops right there. No questions, nothing to explain.”

He said it without ceremony, drying a glass. Like a man agreeing to a perfectly reasonable clause.

Red was the word we always used. The one that stopped everything without needing a reason, without negotiation, without that “are you sure?” look that ruins the saying of it. It was always there, on hand, and that was enough for me not to need the rest.

I stood in the doorway a moment, looking at the blindfold and the rope like they belonged to someone else. I thought, with an uncomfortable clarity and a little pleasant vertigo, that for a long while I wasn’t going to be able to see myself. Not my face in a mirror. Myself. I wasn’t going to know what expression I was wearing, whether the fear showed, or the wanting, or that mix of both I’ve never learned to hide. And he would. He’d see all of it.

That was the part I’d said yes to, months ago, without knowing yet to what exactly. Not the rope. That.

I sat on the edge of the bed because he asked me to, not because I knew why. The blindfold was cloth, not one of those ridiculous elastic sleep masks. He folded it twice before he put it on me; I heard the fabric fold against itself, that dry little sound. Then his hands at the back of my neck, tying it, not too tight, not with nurse’s caution either. Just right. He checked with one finger that it didn’t pull at my temple, and brushed back a strand of hair that had gotten caught underneath. That gesture, the hair, did more to me than the knot did. It was attention to something I couldn’t see him paying attention to.

And then the room was gone.

Not like nightfall. Something else. I knew where the window was because a little light came in under the blindfold, a pale line, but the rest of the room stopped existing as space and became only distances: the mattress under my thighs, the cool air on my arms, his breathing to my left, closer than I expected. I heard myself swallow. It sounded absurdly loud.

The worst part wasn’t not seeing. It was realizing, all at once, that I had no idea what my face was doing. I’ve spent my whole life managing my face. In meetings, with my mother, even in bed. I know when my jaw tightens, I know how to fix an expression before it’s noticed. Not there. I could’ve been wearing anything, fear, hunger, something uglier, and there was no way to know, no way to correct it. And he was right there. Watching. With nothing I could give him back.

That was the first time I thought it clearly, sitting there with my hands still free on my knees: he’s seeing something right now that I’m never going to get to see. And maybe I won’t like it.

I didn’t say red. But the word was there, whole, available, like an exit sign glowing over a door. I left it where it was.

“Ready?” he said.

It wasn’t a question about the rope.

“Yes.”

He led me by the hand to another chair, not the bed. That threw me: I’d pictured the mattress, not hard wood against the backs of my thighs. He sat me down. He tied one wrist and then the other to something behind the chair back, not rope this time, something wider, Velcro, that didn’t bite, and then my ankles, each to a leg of the chair. When he finished, I couldn’t have closed my legs even if I’d wanted to. And I wanted to, a little. Reflex, nothing more.

“Okay?” he said, and ran an open palm through my hair, once, top to bottom, the way you calm an animal.

“Okay.”

I heard his footsteps move away, then the sound of curtain rings sliding on a rod, a dry metallic screech. Then the click of a window opening. Outside air came in, cooler than the room, something green underneath it, damp, distant traffic, and with it a different kind of brightness against the blindfold: not the flat lamp-light from before, something with texture, that shifted when a cloud passed. I was sitting in front of an open window. Dressed, tied, legs spread, with no idea how close the street actually was.

“Can anyone see me?” I asked, and heard my own voice come out thinner than usual.

“If anyone’s looking right now, they’re going to think you’ve got a great view.”

He didn’t answer the question. He answered something else, with that half-smile you could hear even in his voice, and left me right where I didn’t want to be: not knowing. It could have been a joke that only worked if the real answer was no: that I was safe, that he’d never have tied me naked in front of glass if there’d been real risk. Or it could have been joke and truth at once, said sideways, precisely because the truth pleased him too much to say it straight. I didn’t know. And not knowing, sitting there with my legs open and the street air coming straight in, did something I shouldn’t have liked as much as I did.

“You’re an asshole,” I said, low, a smile tucked inside the words, and he laughed, quiet, close to my ear.

“If you ever want me to stop, all you have to do is say so. You know that.”

I did know it. The word was still there, available, as clear as always, and I stayed quiet anyway. That silence said more than any sentence I could have come up with.

“The thrill gets to you as much as it gets to me,” he said then, no mockery in it, almost tender, and the sentence lodged somewhere I hadn’t expected. He wasn’t describing me. He was naming something I’d spent years refusing to say out loud, even to myself, and saying it with the ease of someone who saw nothing there worth judging.

He came back. I felt his hands on my shirt buttons, one by one, unhurried, the backs of his fingers grazing my sternum between each one. Window air touched my skin as the fabric opened, first my throat, then the channel between my breasts, then my stomach. Dressed and undressed at once, in pieces, in front of an open window and a face that couldn’t see any of it. The shame arrived right there, in that gap, not in what he was doing to me, but in the thought of being exposed to something I couldn’t control and couldn’t see. He took it off completely. My bra after. I sat there, bound, bare-chested in the street air, and he said nothing for a stretch that felt long on purpose.

“Beautiful,” he said finally, low, in a voice that didn’t sound like a line. It sounded like something that had slipped out.

He touched me like he had all the time in the world, because he did. Hands first on my shoulders, sliding slowly down my arms to where the Velcro started, then back up, over my throat, my collarbone, the edge of my breasts without ever reaching center, letting me want without letting me ask, because I wasn’t going to beg, not yet. When his thumb finally brushed a nipple I let out a breath I hadn’t known I was holding. I felt him smile without seeing it (there’s a way of staying quiet that sounds like a smile) and he kept going, his other hand easing my knees a little wider, though they couldn’t close anyway.

He knelt. I knew from the change in the height of his breathing, suddenly lower, closer to where I needed him most and could admit it least. He pushed my skirt up to my waist. Window air touched me where no one but him ever had, and I thought, with a stupid kind of clarity threading through everything else, if someone’s looking right now. I didn’t finish the thought. His mouth was already there, direct, no preamble, and everything that had been shame a second before turned into something without a name that clean.

He ate me out slow at first, deliberate, learning me all over again like he hadn’t already memorized every inch, then faster once he found where my legs were shaking against the restraints. Every time I got close, that tension that climbs up from somewhere just ahead of pleasure, giving warning, he pulled back. Not all the way. Just enough to knock the wave down a step and make it build again from lower. He did it three times. On the third I said it myself, without being asked, voice already cracked:

“Please.”

“Not yet.”

I hated that sentence and wanted it again the second he said it. Being tied to that chair, exposed to an open window I couldn’t check, entirely dependent on him deciding when, made me feel used in a way that should have embarrassed me to admit to anyone, and yet the filthiness of that word, used, grew at the same rate as the wanting did. That night I understood they’d never been opposites.

When he finally let me get there, it wasn’t with his mouth. He untied me, hands first, then ankles, quick and practical, a sharp contrast to all the slowness before, and pulled me up from the chair with one hand at my waist, giving me no chance to stand on my own. A few steps. The cold, hard edge of a table against the backs of my thighs, the sense of being in front of the window again, maybe closer now. He bent me forward over the wood. I felt his cock against me before I felt it inside me, one endless second of waiting, and then he pushed in all at once, no warning, and I cried out something that wasn’t a word.

He fucked the way he touched: unhurried when he could afford to be, hard when I asked for it without saying so, one flat hand between my shoulder blades holding me to the table and the other on my hip, setting a rhythm that was his to set, not mine to choose. The window air stayed on me, cold against sweat-damp skin, a constant reminder of where I was and of not knowing who else might know it too. I came with my face against the wood and his name half-formed in my mouth, and felt, a second later, him let go too, his breath breaking against the back of my neck, his weight dropping onto my back for one instant before he pulled away.

I stayed there, bent over the table, heart still going hard, cold air drying the sweat, thinking that I’d gotten through the whole scene without ever knowing what my face had done, what that window had actually seen, and above all, what he had.

If you would like to receive new fiction and notes from Néstor N. Val, you can receive The Letter directly in your inbox. Receive The Letter

The first thing that came back was hearing. The room again, his footsteps, the bathroom tap running for a moment and shutting off. I was still blindfolded. I felt his fingers at the knot behind my neck, working it loose, and I said, without thinking, “wait.” I didn’t want the light yet. He left the blindfold on a few seconds longer, one open hand resting between my shoulder blades, not rubbing, just there, until I was the one who nodded.

When he took it off, the room was darker than I remembered. He’d lowered the blinds at some point I couldn’t have seen. I blinked. He was crouched in front of me, studying my face with a clinical kind of attention that had nothing cold in it, looking for something, a sign that I was okay, or wasn’t. I held his eyes until he found it.

He brought me water. Rubbed my wrists where the rope had left marks, no drama in it, the way you’d check that a hinge still closes. No speeches. That was one of the things I loved most about him: knowing exactly when not to say anything.

He walked to a cabinet I hadn’t even registered that night — furniture that wasn’t ours, part of a place I hadn’t gotten around to noticing — and came back with something between two fingers. A memory card, tiny, black, the label still blank.

“What’s that?” I asked, and heard my own voice land somewhere between curiosity and an alarm I couldn’t yet justify.

“I filmed you.”

It took me a second to react, still processing. I hadn’t seen a camera. Hadn’t felt one, hadn’t heard a single click, nothing that would have given me reason to think there was anything else in that room besides him, me, the chair, the window. And yet I didn’t feel what I expected to feel on learning it, invasion, something close to betrayal, because on some level I already knew it without knowing it: this was the kind of surprise he allowed himself within what we’d agreed. Nothing irreversible. Nothing that touched my life outside that room. A recording he was handing me himself was, if anything, the opposite of a betrayal.

“It’s yours,” he said. “I haven’t watched it. I’m not going to.”

He set it in my palm and closed my fingers over it with his own.

It weighed less than a coin. I thought it was absurd that something so small could unsettle me more than everything before it had. What came before, I’d felt with my body. This, I was going to see. And I had no idea what.

I waited two days. Not out of modesty. Strategy. I wanted to be truly alone, with him out of the apartment, with no chance of him walking in and catching my face while I watched myself.

I plugged the card into my laptop with the blinds down, like whatever was on it might be contagious. Before I hit play, I already had my defense mounted. I know myself. I was going to see myself small. I was going to see a woman tied up, blindfolded, doing as she was told, and that image was going to confirm what I’d suspected about myself for years — that surrendering makes me lesser. That there’s something cheap in giving in like that. I had the answer ready before the question.

I hit play.

The first thing I understood was that the image wasn’t mine. It was his. The camera was his eye: what the screen showed was what he’d been looking at, framed by his attention and not by mine. And that changed everything, because I wasn’t seeing myself the way I thought I saw myself. I was seeing myself the way he saw me.

There were a few seconds at the start, before he did anything, where the camera just held on my face. Me, sitting in the chair, freshly bound, blindfold on, hands already fixed behind the chair back, with no idea those seconds even existed. And the face I was wearing wasn’t the one I’d dreaded. There was nothing cheap in it. There was a woman waiting, jaw a little tight, lips parted, holding herself in check. The camera didn’t look away. It stayed. Like whatever it was looking at deserved to be looked at.

That unsettled me more than anything else, and the scene hadn’t even started yet.

Then it moved toward the window, and there I saw what I hadn’t been able to see that night: before drawing the curtain and opening the glass, the camera lingered a second on the windowsill. A tall plant, broad-leafed, placed right where it would block any angle from the building across the street. I hadn’t noticed it walking in with the bags still half-unpacked. He’d put it there, on purpose, at some point I wasn’t looking, thinking ahead to a moment that didn’t exist yet.

It took me an uncomfortable second to understand what he’d actually done with my question. “If anyone’s looking right now, they’re going to think you’ve got a great view.” I heard myself call him an asshole, heard him laugh low, close to my ear, before saying the other thing: “If you ever want me to stop, all you have to do is say so. You know that.” There, on the screen, I watched the silence that came after, mine, and understood what that silence had meant even before I heard his next line.

“The thrill gets to you as much as it gets to me.”

He’d said it without mockery. The camera didn’t move when he said it, didn’t hunt for my reaction the way you would if you were chasing an effect: it just held there, steady, like he didn’t need to check anything either, like he already knew he’d been right. Watching it now, with that sentence back in my ears, hit me the same way it had that first night. Maybe worse. He hadn’t been describing me. He’d been naming, out loud, something I’d spent years not saying even to myself, with the ease of someone who saw nothing there to be ashamed of. Which meant the plant hadn’t been a lie, either, and it hadn’t been reassurance. It had been the exact truth, dressed up as a joke, said knowing I wouldn’t be able to decode it in time, leaving me with the fear intact on purpose, when a plain “there’s a plant, don’t worry” would have taken the weight off in half a second. He could have. He chose to let me carry that uncertainty through the whole scene instead, tied and exposed with no way to know if I really was. That should have bothered me. Watching it, what I felt instead was closer to vertigo than anger: that he knew me well enough to work out how much real fear he could hand me without it stopping me from wanting it, and knew me even better, to put words to the thing I’d never once dared to name myself.

I watched my own buttons come open one by one under his fingers, the frame moving down my chest at the same pace as the fabric, and I recognized in my body, not in the image, in the body, that same exact shame from that night, the shame of being exposed to something I couldn’t control. The camera, though, didn’t see it as shame. It held on my bare chest a beat too long, almost reverent, before he said “beautiful” in that voice that had sounded, to me, like it had slipped out. Watching it now, I knew he’d been right. That hadn’t sounded like a line. It had sounded like someone looking at something he hadn’t expected to hurt this much to have in front of him.

He knelt. The camera went down with him, and what it caught between my open legs wasn’t a clinical shot, nothing cold about it: it was close to reverent, the kind of look you give something you’ve been waiting for. I watched my own face when his mouth arrived, the jolt of it, and then I watched the three times he pulled back right as I was about to get there, and each time, the camera climbed for a second toward my face to check how I was taking it before dropping back down. He hadn’t been toying with me for fun. He’d been watching. When I said “please” with my voice already breaking, and heard his answer, “not yet,” it landed differently than it had blind, where it had sounded like pure control. Now it sounded like a man holding himself back too.

When it got to the table (the part I’d dreaded most, bent forward with him inside me and the open window right behind) I made myself keep watching. And what the screen gave back wasn’t what I’d built in my head over two days. The camera wasn’t looking down at me with the distance of someone using something. It was low, close, fixed on the point where my face pressed into the wood every time he drove in, and it never looked away, not even when he came and his breath broke against the back of my neck. I watched my own face come undone with his name half-formed on my lips, and for once it didn’t embarrass me, because the woman on that screen wasn’t the one I’d been carrying around. She was better than that. She was someone being looked at well.

I paused the video once, near the end. Not to catch my breath. To sit with the fact that the defense I’d walked in with didn’t hold up anymore. I couldn’t tell myself I’d made myself small. The proof was right there, in his eye: through the whole scene, while he owned me, while he tied me and denied me and pushed me to the edge and fucked me against a table in front of a window whose real risk only he knew, he’d been looking at me with an attention that had nothing to do with contempt. It looked like the opposite. Something closer to reverence than to use. And I didn’t have a comfortable word for the opposite.

I hit play again. Watched the whole thing through. When it ended, I sat with the black screen for a while, my own faint reflection looking back at me, and understood that something had been taken from me. Not an item of clothing. An alibi. I couldn’t tell myself anymore that surrendering made me small. I’d seen it through his eyes, and through his eyes I wasn’t small in a single frame. I was, frame by frame, the closest thing to a goddess anyone had ever looked at me like.

It was the most unsettling thing that had happened to me in a very long time.

I kept the card. Didn’t delete it.

Not for what he did to me that night. I had that in my body, didn’t need a file to remember it. I kept it for those strange three seconds at the start of the video, before the camera had done anything but look at me, when I sat in that chair believing I was wearing one expression and was wearing another. I’d walked into that room afraid of seeing myself made small.

I didn’t see myself small.

I saw myself seen. Which is a different thing. And a harder one to give back.